HMMM Let me think.

1 8 in dildo
2 medium butt plugs
1 small butt plug
1 anal screw
2 coil vibrators
1 micro vibe
1 red vibe with a light in the tip
1 set of anal beads
1 wartenburg wheel
1 riding crop
1 glass dildo curved great for gspot play vaginal and anal
1 double ended dildo (wife hates it says it's too big I bought it as a joke because it was only $20)

I know we have a lot more than that but those are the things we actually use. We used to buy either a sex toy or a sex book once a month. It was a good way to keep things spicy.