There is a show that I watch that covers the NFL and in a weekly segment that covers stupid decisions, plays, or things that players do in the course of a game, that is called What were they thinking.

I know that I'm a little late to the American Idol thing, but what in the HELL were some of the contestants thinking. Let's face it if you are going to be on a TV show, you have to have either Talent OR Looks, but on Idol, both is a requirement-admitted or inferred.

So tell me, what were they thinking?